Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness
About ISC Contact Us Search
Competition and Firm Strategy Competition and Economic Development Competition and Society

Expanding Profitability While Confronting Global Challenges

 Panel discussion moderated by Michael E. Porter
 
Clinton Global Initiative Annual Meeting
 
September 27, 2007

Many businesses are learning that they are able to increase their profits by adapting models that empower consumers and workers while reducing environmental degradation. By integrating socially responsible principles into their corporate strategies, companies have been able to make impressive financial gains while improving the communities in which they operate. This panel, moderated by Michael E. Porter explores how businesses are able to increase profitability by refining their social and environmental practices. Panelists include Chief Executive Officer of Swiss Reinsurance Company, Jacques Aigrain, President and CEO of the Starbucks Coffee Company, Jim Donald, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of MTV Networks, Judy McGrath, and Chairman and Managing Director of Suzlon Energy Ltd., Tulsi Tanti.

See below for Michael Porter's remarks introducing the panel discussion.  A full transcript, video, and podcast of the session are also available.  Michael Porter's remarks begin at 21min 37sec on the video.

MICHAEL PORTER: Well, it’s always hard to go after a session like that. I have actually never been able to attend this meeting before, and I asked President Clinton just to stop for a minute and watch the first bit of this, but I want to congratulate him and his entire team for putting this on. President Clinton and I used to play golf together on New Year’s Day, a number of years in a row, and I can tell you confidentially that he is a so-so golfer. He’s fun. He’s energetic, but you know, results so-so. But I’ll tell you, he’s a world-class organizer and motivator and this thing is just phenomenal. So, President Clinton, congratulations on this whole effort.

This session this afternoon is a little bit different than the other sessions you have all attended. You have been going to sessions that have really been organized around particular areas of social concern or social issues, health, climate, poverty and so forth. This session aims to look across those topics and really look at the role of the corporation as an institution in society to address social needs. Why are we interested in this? Well, we know that corporations have extraordinary resources with which to tackle almost any problem. The have money. They have purchasing power. They have skills. They have managerial capacity. They have all kinds of assets and all kinds of leverage points with which to address social issues. The question is how to actually mobilize the corporation and harness the corporation’s capacity in this area, how to really use the market system to address social issues as well as obviously create the employment and economic growth that we all depend on.

So what we have here today is a series of senior business leaders, CEOs, who are really innovators in how to rethink and reshape the role of the corporation in addressing the social agenda items that you have been talking about today, often in a very different context. What I’d like to do is just introduce this panel with just a few thoughts about how I think we are starting to transform and reshape the whole model of how corporations engage society We’ve gone through a long history here. I think stage one was the era which I would like to call pressure politics. Corporations resisted addressing these issues. It’s not my job. And there were pressure politics of various kinds to kind of cajole and enforce and embarrass companies into doing something. That was stage one. We moved some time ago into another stage, which I would call the CSR stage. We want to be responsible corporations. We want to have social responsibility departments. We want to really support a lot of charitable causes. And I think we made tremendous headway in that stage, and many companies got much, much more engaged in trying to be sensitive to addressing these social issues. But I think what’s happening now is that we’re entering really a third stage, and this is the stage of what I would call the stage of really shared value. Rather than seeing this as something you have to pressure corporations to do, rather than for corporations to see this as charitable, we are now starting to enter an era where corporations are starting to rethink — the leading ones are starting to rethink how they can better integrate their connections with society in order to create shared value. Society benefits. The company benefits.

Now, what are some of the elements of this new model? Well, I think one of the key elements is it starts with best practices on all the impacts the company has. So companies have to be sensitive to energy use. They have to be sensitive to environmental impact, to wasted packaging, to hiring practices. This new model starts with best practice on all those impacts, but it goes far beyond that now. The new model moves away from PR and branding, which is what a lot of the CSR thinking was all about — how can we use this to bolster our brand image — to actual social impact. How can we actually make a difference? How can we actually get something done? The model moves from supporting many, many, many social causes with little bits of money and donations and volunteer programs in 25 or 30 different areas, to starting to focus the company’s efforts on two or three or four areas, where they actually have the tools to really make a difference, but make a difference in an area where, again, there is this win-win or shared value opportunity, where it benefits society but it also benefits the business.

And then, finally, I would say that this new model requires that companies be very strategic about what social issues they take on, and they select those issues very carefully, based on their business, based on the tools and the skills that they have available. I think we have a panel today that will give us a window, a glimpse, into this new model. And I would like to thank all the panelists for being part of today’s session.

So let’s start with Tulsi. Tulsi, can you make money doing social good?...

 

 

For additional related content, please see the Institute website section on Corporate Philanthropy.

For information about materials not available online, please email iscadmin@hbs.edu.
HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL HBS HOME HU HOME